I oppose curbs on immigration. Let the folks in.
If you lose your job to someone who is a fresh arrival, you just have a shit job and have wasted your life. Step your game up, dont hate!
It's not necessarily about having a shit job. Unless you're at the executive level, corporations are more than happy to replace you with a foreign worker who'll work for less money than an American worker. No illegal is going to take my job. But some guy with an H1B Visa might. Just as some corporations are more than happy to hire cheap, illegal labor, most support opening up the H1B program, because they can get dirt cheap, technically skilled labor for up to six years. NAFTA was supported by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, the California Chamber of Commerce and most of the business lobby. Bill Gates (and quite a few other tech billionaires) is in favor of opening up H1B. I understand we don't turn out enough kids who are are skilled in math and science. But IMO, the answer to that (near the top) is not to flood the market with cheap, "legal" labor from India and Pakistan. And the answer (near the bottom) is not to flood the market with cheap, illegal labor.
To the best of my knowledge, at least H1B holders pay taxes here. But I can empathize with the frustrated citizens in places like Arizona, New Mexico, Texas and California. Apart from the crime issue, the social cost of having so many people in your area who don't/can't pay taxes is unsustainable. Bush cobbled together that unfunded mandate known as "No Child Left Behind". Skyraider mentioned Tennessee. I know for a fact that many areas of Tennessee have seen property taxes go up by 100% or better because they've had to fund teachers and staff to educate the children of migrant workers (some legal, but many illegal) who showed up in their school districts.
I have nothing against Mexicans, Pakistanis, Indians or anybody else. But IMO, we do have to have laws (that are enforced) that deal with who can and who can't legally be in the U.S. I am against NAFTA, and always have been. I am for free (FAIR!) trade. I am for legal immigration... that is also fair, and not just a backdoor way to depress wages in this country.
Except for a few (dozen) personality quirks, I think I'm a fairly reasonable guy. But without meaningful immigration reform and control over our southern border, even people like me are going to reach the point of maximum frustration... and at that point, I might not seem quite so reasonable anymore. If I lived in Texas, Arizona or New Mexico, and there were people running across my land every night, you'd have probably already seen me on CNN or Fox News (as the case may be
). If I even catch a whisper of someone hunting on my land without my permission, I get overly aggressive - if you're on my land and you see me staring at you with an AK-47 slung over my shoulder and a big drum mag hanging out of it, I'm not there to ask you if you saw any big deer that day. Can you imagine how goofy I'd get if my land was a walking highway for illegals? Nah, that dog just don't hunt.
Let's get some meaningful reform in place that's fair, but that is also going to address the issue. This is a problem! Both sides of the political spectrum need to recognize that fact.