Seriously? You can't believe it's that simple.So, it's OK to not win your division title, your conference title AND lose head-to-head with a team that did both and still be considered better? What the fuck?
Try to remember how the playoff committe works. When they're trying to compare a 1-loss team vs a 2-loss team, they look at the wins and how they won, AND they look at the losses and how they lost.
Ohio State beat Michigan.
Michigan beat Penn State (actually, Michigan BEAT THE SHIT out of Penn State)
And, did you watch the game, Penn State vs Ohio State? Penn State's offense looked fucking horrible! They won because their defense and special teams played like monsters. They playoff committee is certainly going to consider that. What is that offense gonna look like against a far-better defense like Alabama's?