Holy shit the Blues absolutely destroyed the Oilers on national TV last night! Vladimir Tarasenko had 2 goals, 2 assists and the Gordie Howe hat-trick, Schenn scored twice and had 2 assists and Schwartz scored a goal and added 2 assists....the top line had 11 points as St. Louis romped to an 8-3 shellacking of the Oilers. Edmonton looks lost right now and might have quit on McLellan in the second period. I had serious doubts about the Blues after preseason injuries to Berglund, Steen and Bouwmeester figured to translate to a slow start. Then, when Fabbri was lost for the season I figured we were done. In actuality, the reverse has happened as they have bolted to a 16-5-1 record after 22 games and have put together what is possibly the most potent line in the NHL (with all due respect to the Lightning). The Schenn-for-Lehtera trade with Philly looks like highway robbery at this point....he's been absolutely awesome after they moved him to center. Don't get me wrong.....I'm not exactly saving up for tickets to the Cup finals yet but, so far, things couldn't be working out much better than they are. I love Hitch but firing him last year and hiring Mike Yeo has totally changed the complexion of this team from a defensive-oriented dump-and-chase mentality to an aggressive power and speed game that has included some very robust scoring from the defensemen. We'll face a big test at home against Nashville on Friday and will finish the homestand by playing Minnesota, Anaheim and the Kings so it will be a good barometer of where we are compared to the other elite teams in the conference.
In the meantime, I'm not sure what to make of Edmonton. They need to snap out of the funk they are in pretty soon or they may fall out of contention altogether. What the hell has happened to them? Toward the end of last season, they looked to be a serious team on the rise. Now, they just look lost.
The Blues are definitely off to a great start. I'm happy for you. I would love to see them win their first Cup (but probably not a bet I would make despite their great start).
As for the Oilers, a lot falls on the GM. When you build your team up and go on a nice run and excitement builds and expectations grow, you have to keep improving the roster (just look at the Houston Astros in MLB; they built a team around drafting and player development and then signed/acquired the veterans and stars they needed (e.g. Brian McCann, Carlos Beltran, Josh Reddick, Justin Verlander) to put them over the top and win their first ever World Series), and Peter Chiarelli has not done that. In fact, our team is significantly less deep than it was last season. Not having Andrej Sekera (our best defenceman) in the lineup all season so far definitely hurts. But when you have that big of a hole to fill you can't just rely on things falling into place like they did last season, you have to go out and find someone to fill that hole. And Chiarelli didn't do that. Don't get me wrong, he's made some good moves. And you can't argue with taking a bottom-dweller to the playoffs in just two seasons as GM (and
significantly improving what had been our biggest hole for years and years, namely, defence). But the writing was on the wall for our ascension the moment we won the first overall pick to land Connor McDavid. And with a player like that (which gives you a serious chance to be a contender) you have to build a team around him.
Some of the moves he's made have really set us back in terms of roster development and depth. Taylor Hall for Adam Larsson is a bad trade. Period. Yes, we needed defence, yes defence is exorbitantly costly in today's NHL (both in terms of actual dollars and in terms of the value in players/picks you have to give up to acquire it), but an elite NHL scorer (top ten according to advanced metrics) for a #4 defenceman? I like Larsson, he's good, but you simply
cannot make moves wherein you give up so much more value than you get back and hope to be a successful franchise. Couple that with the fact that Chiarelli followed up that trade by using the cap space that Hall's departure created to sign Milan Lucic to a big money long-term deal, and it's obvious why we're regressing now. Lucic is a big fat slow player who was never going to fit in with the Oilers top forwards (who are all speedy skilled guys). I like Lucic, he tries really hard, and you can see that he worked hard this past offseason to get in better shape and gain some speed on the ice. But he just doesn't fit. That was a
bad signing.
And then there's the Jordan Eberle for Ryan Strome trade. I don't like Eberle. In fact, I despise him forever for the way that he quit on the team in the playoffs last year. I have
never in my life seen someone play with less heart and less effort in the postseason that Eberle last year. It was a disgrace.
But... he's a top-six forward. No question. He's a perennial 20-25 goal, 50-60 point guy. There's value in that. His value was at an all-time low following his dreadful postseason, so why pull the trigger on a trade now??? Why not wait until his value has been built back up a bit and then trade him and get some decent value in return. Furthermore, you can't trade a top-six forward away with
absolutely no plan on how to fill that hole. You didn't honestly think that Ryan Strome would fill that hole, did you? He has provided no evidence to suggest that he can be a consistent top-six producer in the NHL. And, again, it's an inexcusable mismatch in value for a 1-for-1 trade.
And then there's the trade for Griffin Reinhart. I mean, SMH, for fuck's sake. We trade
two picks for him (which turned out to be the 16th and 33rd
overall picks in the 2015 draft). Why? Why? Why? That 16th pick ended up being Mathew Barzal, a young forward I would give up my left nut to have, and who is lighting it up for the Islanders in his rookie season. And to top it all off, we lost Reinhart to Las Vegas in the expansion draft. Of course we did. That trade is nothing short of a debacle.
The reason we're off to such a bad start is because we're honestly not that good. And that is in no small part due to the fact that Peter Chiarelli is a bad GM.