tunsty said:
To those who say 'yes'..
Would you forfeit your life for any of the following:
#3000 people who die of lung cancer, as a result of smoking?
#3000 people who die from drug taking?
#3000 people who die from HIV/Aids?
#3000 people who die from 'natural causes'?
#3000 people who commit suicide?
#3000 starving children in Africa?
I would be interested to know whether any of the above lives are worth saving..
or 3000 people in car accidents
or 3000 people dying from tetanus
or 3000 people dying in unicycle accidents?
No no no to all of them. And for so many reasons. Dying in 9/11 was an arbritrary death and I would not give my life just to prevent the 9/11 attack from killing 3000 people. Nor would I give my life for 3000 cancer victims or for ANY particular set of 3000 people.
Now, I WOULD give my life it were guaranteed to stop all future senseless acts of violence. But just to stop the 9/11 attack from happening? No way, because there are plenty of other things coming around the corner and they all happen in the course of shaping world history and if I can't stop them all then why stop any of them when all that does is allow its substitute to occur?
Just to make a point here:
What about 3000 people from dying from natural causes?
Anyone who would answer yes to that one is an enemy of the human race. The world is already becoming overwhelmed and our constant unnatural tinkering with cycle of life is damaging enough.