I'm sick of all this movie hype lately. I really don't see how this can be compared to Sin City because it's not the same people making it. yeah, it's frank miller writing it.. but who here has really read anything by frank miller? not most of the people that saw and liked Sin City, so they really don't know how he is as a writer. Even I haven't read 300, although I am familiar with it. It just seems to me to be the case where people are jumping onto the bandwagon of these movies that are thought to be like artistic, when they really aren't the kind of people that would ever go and see a movie like this if it was playing in a ral art house cinema and not a top box office smash. Maybe it's just good marketting. I don't know.
It just reminds me how everyone was soo exciting about Clerks 2, when I never heard anyone ever buzzing about any of kevin smiths other movies.
Whew...
Hey, Grumpy! Snow White and the other 6 dwarves are getting a little annoyed with you; they feel you are avoiding your duties at the rockworks taking all those polls on "who saw Sin City and also read other Frank Miller works?",
"would you go see a multimillion Dollar movie if it was playing only in a real small Art House Cinema?", and "Did you talk about any other Kevin Smith flicks while being excited about Clerks 2?".
Like you, I am familiar with the story of 300, while not having actually read it (I am assuming the 300 Spartans has been made into an Illustrated Novel called 300), but if there is a review on rottentomatoes.com, and trailers on the 'site, the flick isn't exactly a complete secret; most people are looking forward to seeing it, no one here has actually said it's a great movie (yet).
Unlike you, I make as few unsupported declarations of fact as possible...maybe the writing sucks and Frank Miller can't really carry a story through from print to film, and maybe the director didn't do a good job translating print to special fx scenes...won't be long 'till we all know.
So far, no one seems to have noticed the lack of quality, and there just may be a good reason for that...it could be a really cool movie.