The Three Stooges.......Best Comedy Team Ever ?

No idea why I am bothering to respond, but I am. You can't make a claim for "greatest comedy team" because of the different genres. The Stooges were great at what they did, the Marx Bros. were phenomenal at what they did. Python were more my speed, but they built on what others had done. They would all probably suck if they tried to do what the others did. Adele can sing but I don't want her fronting Iron Maiden any time soon.

Excellent point, well stated.

Here is one of my favorite comedy sketches, which works so well because of the characters & interactions of Pete & Dud - if you were to try plugging others into those roles, I doubt it would be so funny.

 
I never was a fan of the British Comedy. I simply never laughed when I saw their acts. Especially Monty Python. I guess I just didn't "get" their humor. However, I thoroughly enjoyed A Fish Called Wanda.

My faves are:

The Three Stooges

Abbott & Costello (Who's On First?)

Ralph Kramden & Ed Norton
 
No idea why I am bothering to respond, but I am. You can't make a claim for "greatest comedy team" because of the different genres. The Stooges were great at what they did, the Marx Bros. were phenomenal at what they did. Python were more my speed, but they built on what others had done. They would all probably suck if they tried to do what the others did. Adele can sing but I don't want her fronting Iron Maiden any time soon.



This is true. As for myself, i laugh my butt off watching the stooges more than when i would watch other comedy teams. For me, The Three Stooges never get stale. Maybe Adele could belt out some metal vocals.
 
Maybe it's my age, my upbringing, or just my puerile sense of humour, but for me it's Rik Mayall and Ade Edmondson in anything they've written and performed in together.

tumblr_mocctgavdv1svsahho1_500.jpg


Wrongly derided as mere cock 'n' fart humour, their stuff also had some very intelligently scripted dialogue and clever wordplay. My favourite exchange between the pair might have been completing the crossword in Bottom episode "Culture" but I think it's narrowly pipped by (also from Bottom) the post-looting conversation about the duck from "Carnival."

tumblr_mocdmr4K2u1svsahho1_500.jpg


Eddie: Still, at least we got the duck. [holds up a small yellow rubber-ducky]
Richie: The duck?
Eddie: Yeah! It's made out of plastic!
Richie: Eddie, what, in the name of Greek Buggery, is the use of a plastic duck?
Eddie: It floats in the bath. ['floats' the duck up to Richie] Hello!
Richie: But why?
Eddie: It's hollow!
Richie: No... (exasperated) I mean : why the duck??
Eddie: It came free with the telly.
Richie: (angry) Eddie, everything came free with the telly!! We were looting! Why didn't you get a free telly with the telly?!
Eddie: Well it'd sink in the bath!!

OK the live shows were a bit ropey, but the three series of the tv show were golden. And the Young Ones was possibly better still. Possibly my favourite bit of TV ever is the argument between Rik and Vyv about who gets the bedroom, Vyv throwing all his clothes on the floor as if to prove it, Rik throwing the clothes out of the window, and Vyv's characteristically violent response.

tumblr_mocdjr1y821svsahho1_1280.jpg


"Neil, your bedroom's on fire!!"

Just the look they give each other before sprinting out of the inferno and shouting in unison creases me ; as much as they hate each other, they unite in an instant in the opportunity to offload their problem on Neil.





Who are these people? What's wrong with them??

As i'm not familiar with these groups, i do remember watching The Goodies back in the day. Is the first group them ?
 
Nothing wrong with that. Who are they ?

The three gentlemen in that photo are Bill Corbett, Mike Nelson, and Kevin Murphy of "Mystery Science Theater 3000" fame, but they have continued doing hilarious riffing on movies, under some different titles.

I don't really have a "best" team, because I think they were all different. I personally get a little tired out on the Stooges, but absolutely LOVE the Marx Brothers- because it's the right combination of razor wit, physical humor, pantomime, and at times, a brand of humor that seems to have eventually made its way into the Zucker/Abrams films.
 
While I am an a superior American, I must say some Brits have put me on the floor laughing. The Young Ones were brilliant, albeit a bit weird...ok, a lot weird.
Also Red Dwarf, Monty Python (nothing in time will ever equal their overall body of work), and an expat Brit named Bob Hope, who teamed with Bing Crosby was fuckin' hilarious. The Stooges never rose to the intellectual brilliance of "Who's on First", but slapstick done by Abbott and Costello was side splitting.
I still laugh out loud at the Marx Brothers.
Jane Curtain with Gilda Radner doing Emmylou Latella, and Rosanna RosannaDanna, hell, the whole cast of the Not Ready For Prime Time Players was fuckin' brilliant. Bass O Matic, Puppy Uppers, who doesn't have examples of those guys?
Face it...the Stooges were great, but an acquired taste. I loved the movie, it captured the insanity that was the Stooges. Which group are you thinking about, BTW, with Shep or with Curley?

I thought Shemp was underrated and even though i liked Curly, i enjoyed Shemp a bit more. Both were great ! I liked the Stooges in the short 20 minute clips and not the movies.

Also, the others you have named were all good too. The local PBS station here years ago showed some of the British acts like The Goodies, Red Dwarf. I loved ''Nelson's Column'' but only 2 seasons were shown here i think.
 

bobjustbob

Proud member of FreeOnes Hall Of Fame. Retired to
Before I forget to mention, I don't put Lucy and Rickey there. She was a star before Castro was born. Her best stuff was done alone.


Shemp was great. He got a call from Moe about Curly. Got out of his movie contract and died as a Stooge.


Somebody mentioned Gleason and Carney. Great but I'd settle them down to fourth or sixth.
 
The Goons - Harry Secombe, Peter Sellers and the inimitable Spike Milligan who wrote most of this anarchic humour.


The Goodies - Tim Brooke-Taylor, Graeme Garden and Bill Oddie.


The Goodies were shown here years ago on the local PBS tv station and I thought they were hilarious. Never heard of The Goon Show but remember Peter Sellers. Glad you posted it !
 
Top