It's painful to watch edmonton so far this year besides Eberle and Hall for the most part. Penner and Gilbert are the softest big guys I have ever seen play. Penner has no motivation at all and Gilbert gives the puck away close to every shift.
Tom Gilbert is indeed a turnover machine. And brutal turnovers at that. I am dead serious when I say that I have never hated a player as much as I hate Tom Gilbert. I despise him. He looks like a diseased lizard.
Honestly, Hall hasn't been fun to watch at all, he's constantly getting pushed off the puck. He needs to toughen up in a big way.
Eberle has been great to watch though, on both sides of the ice.
It's funny, Penner's first year with the Oilers he had no motivation and was so slow and put in no effort (I think he was eating too many cheeseburgers and doughnuts), but then last season he was phenomenal from beginning to end, he never quit on the puck, he hustled, and he had a career year (and he induced a complete 180 on my opinion of him). Now this year he's almost reverted back to the Dustin Penner that he was in his first season with the Oilers (though not quite).
I made a stupidly optimistic and knee-jerk reaction prediction for the Oilers to make playoffs and the Stanley Cup Finals after watching them spank the Flames to open the season, but obviously I'm not going to stick by that prediction. A bottom-five in the NHL and bottom-three in the West finish is likely, and I think we could finish second-last to the Islanders. If that be the case, we'll get another high draft pick, which would be great considering the path we're on now.
On the bright side, to me it looks like all our young guns are poised to break out at right around the same time. Pääjärvi (who has been terrible; pointless in his last ten), Hall, Eberle, and possibly most important of all, Dubnyk (who has played very well since Khabibulin went on the IR, especially for a guy with so little experience in the NHL so far) all could hit their stride in two or three seasons, which will give us a two or three-year window from then before we lose them all to free agency (because, let's face it, the Oilers are pretty much just a farm team for the rest of the NHL).