MLB Trivia

The Mets completed a triple play today which inspired this question. It is possible to record a triple play with the ball never being fielded. Explain how.

I will try....Batter is called out, runner on third called out on an attempt to steal home plate, runner on second, thinking that was the third out runs off the the field and is tagged the catcher. Thus, unassisted triple play.
 

bobjustbob

Proud member of FreeOnes Hall Of Fame. Retired to
I will try....Batter is called out, runner on third called out on an attempt to steal home plate, runner on second, thinking that was the third out runs off the the field and is tagged the catcher. Thus, unassisted triple play.

That would be an unassisted triple play but the catcher is fielding the ball when making tags.
 
That would be an unassisted triple play but the catcher is fielding the ball when making tags.

Guess your definition of fielding throws me for a loop. 1st, the ball never entered fair territory. What exactly did the catcher field. I would think catching balls/strikes would not be fielding because it is not computed in fielding pct. nor as chances. So in your def of fielding don't think this can happen. Agree?
 

John_8581

FreeOnes Lifetime Member
Let me try this as Pool Hustler has set the stage here, and Bob has said his approval on the first two outs ...


Infield fly rule must be involved somehow. I can come up with a double play adding the trailing runner passing the lead runner while the ball is in flight. But the third out? You got me on that one.

Because the infield fly rule is called, yes the batter is automatically out for the first out. And yes, what pool hustler said with trail runner (runner on 1B) passing the lead runner (runner on 2B) for out number two. When the infield fly rule is engaged, the other runners on base can advance on their own accord. Thus, our lead runner goes back to second base and tries to tag up and advance to third base but he is somehow called out on interference with the fielder covering second base while in the midst of trying to tag up.... A triple play without the ball being fielded.

However, if it is fielder obstruction based on the umpire's decision, then the umpire would award our lead runner third base. Therefore, it would only be a double play and not a triple play.

Either way, it would look like mass confusion on the basepaths... be it a double play or a triple play.
 

bobjustbob

Proud member of FreeOnes Hall Of Fame. Retired to
@Panther. When a catcher catches a 3rd strike he is credited with a putout and with men on base the ball is still in play. The catcher also gets charged a fielding error when he allows a passed ball.

@John. Got it. Interfering with the fielder attempt to field a ball. Also if when the infield fly comes down and hits the runner, that's the 3rd out.
 

bobjustbob

Proud member of FreeOnes Hall Of Fame. Retired to
Daniel Murphy of my Mets is such a good hitter but a fucking butcher at second base. This inspired me to a question.

Since the age of expansion, only 3 players have had more than 30 errors in a season at 2nd base. Juan Samuel, Alan Wiggins, and which Hall of Famer?
 
Daniel Murphy of my Mets is such a good hitter but a fucking butcher at second base. This inspired me to a question.

Since the age of expansion, only 3 players have had more than 30 errors in a season at 2nd base. Juan Samuel, Alan Wiggins, and which Hall of Famer?

Sandeberg?
 

feller469

Moving to a trailer in Fife, AL.
batter hits a grand slam, none of the runners run, the batter passes all three? Not sure if the lead runner is out or the trail runner. Or some combination of runners passing the runner ahead of them...

All of a sudden, I have the image of Willie Stargell trying to call timeout after he tried to steal second, slid and stopped about two feet from the base.
 
batter hits a grand slam, none of the runners run, the batter passes all three? Not sure if the lead runner is out or the trail runner. Or some combination of runners passing the runner ahead of them...

All of a sudden, I have the image of Willie Stargell trying to call timeout after he tried to steal second, slid and stopped about two feet from the base.

Not a grand slam unless there are 4 runs scored. Once the ball is it it is in play. In this case, 1 RBI by hitter.
 
[B][URL="https://www.freeones.com/panther said:
Panther[/URL][/B], post: 8543656, member: 26138"]What MLB starting pitcher had nickname "Mudcat"?

Jim "Mudcat" Grant with the Cleveland Indians.
 
Sandeberg?

Don't think so. His fielding was consistently outstanding. Doubt he ever even made 20 in a year.
I don't think it's Alomar (unless it happened very early in his career?)
So who does that leave? Joe Morgan? Don't think he ever made 30. Ok I'm stumped. Tempted to google but I won't :1orglaugh
 

bobjustbob

Proud member of FreeOnes Hall Of Fame. Retired to
Rod Carew

Cash your ticket.

The Manager of the Year Award has been handed out since 1983.

Only 1 team has had 5 winners.
Only 2 teams never had one.
Only 1 manager had a losing record. (Hint: He is currently active.)
 
Cash your ticket.

The Manager of the Year Award has been handed out since 1983.

Only 1 team has had 5 winners.
Only 2 teams never had one.
Only 1 manager had a losing record. (Hint: He is currently active.)

1. Only 1 team has had 5 winners
I'm guessing it's either the Yankees or Braves, I'll pick the Yankees.

2.Only 2 teams never had one.
Here again I'm guessing the Cubs and perhaps the Indians.

3. Only 1 manager had a losing record. (Hint: He is currently active).
Another guess, Lloyd McClendon with the Pirates.
 

feller469

Moving to a trailer in Fife, AL.
never would have guessed the 5-time franchise. was pretty sure on losing record. no clue on none. Great question(s)
 

feller469

Moving to a trailer in Fife, AL.
Who holds the distinction of having the lowest batting average to win a batting title?
 
Top