I, for one, am happy the Sox didn't sign Bay. He put up numbers we're unlikely to never see again. And with the Mets, it wouldn't surprise me if he flounders quickly.
In theory, what you propose could work for Boston. It could work to atleast get them to the All Star Break and they can evaluate if there's a hot stick somewhere for a trade.
In reality, what you describe--> Solid Pitching + Solid Defense + Small Run Scoring = the San Diego Padres
The Padres haven't really done much at all...:dunno:
Ah, but there's a problem there.
You're right, that's what the Padres
preach, however in reality, the past three years they're 22nd in FIP, and 23rd in tRA. That tells you their pitching has been abysmal. Their offense is next to last in both OPS+ and wRAA over that same time period, and their defense is 26th in UZR over that same period. So while they preach that, what they've fielded is offensive suck, with a side of pitching mediocrity, and an extra helping of defensive suck. So while I see what you're trying to say, the comparison is flawed to say the least.
Add to that the fact that no one in the Padres organization can even come close in any meaningful pitching metric to the Sox starters, and you've got a basic idea of why the Sox are in good position.