The Final Four this year shows that young coaches in college hoops shouldn't be overlooked. Butler hired Stevens when he was 30; now he's 34. VCU hired Smart when he was 31; now he's 33. But what's interesting is that Calipari and Calhoun began their head coaching careers at a younger age than even Stevens and Smart, and that's not something I'm sure the average person realizes. Calhoun was 29 when he got his first head job; Calipari was 29, too.
That means the four men at this Final Four received their first NCAA head coaching positions when they were, on average, 29.8 years of age, and yet, in the Year 2011, athletic directors are still mostly hesitant to hire somebody so young and inexperienced. More often than not, a Division I athletic director will pass on a young guy in favor of someone more advanced in age.
Take the Cal State-Bakersfield search, for instance. Bakersfield AD Jeff Konya this week hired Rod Barnes - a 45-year-old veteran who has been fired from Ole Miss and Georgia State in the past five years, and a man whose last eight years as a head coach have produced zero winning seasons. Yes, Barnes is a former National Coach of the Year, but that was 10 years ago and more situational than anything else. Yes, Barnes has over 180 Division I wins under his belt, but he has more than 180 Division I losses under his belt, too. His career record is 185-187.
Ole Miss and Georgia State may be hard jobs, but they're not that hard - or at least they shouldn't be. Regardless, neither job is as hard as the Cal State-Bakersfield job, which is why I can't think of a single reason why a Southern man who couldn't win in Mississippi or Georgia is going to suddenly start winning in California. If this doesn't end well, Konya can always argue that he hired a former National Coach of the Year with more than 180 wins. You know, somebody with a réresumé. The alternative would've been to gamble on a young coach, and athletic directors aren't usually into gambling as much as they're into making a move that's perceived safe.
Northeastern gambled in 1971 when it hired a 29-year-old Calhoun, and it worked. UMass gambled in 1988 when it hired a 29-year-old Calipari, and it worked, too (well, for awhile). Nearly two decades later, Butler gambled on Stevens, then VCU gambled on Smart. Now all four men are in need of just two more wins to claim the 2011 national championship.
My only point is that a good athletic director should be able to examine candidates, find the right guy for his job and pull the trigger. In some cases, the right guy might be a 50-year-old veteran. But I've long believed great coaches are often identifiable at a young age, always admired athletic directors with the you-know-whats to take a chance on one. With any luck, this group of coaches at this Final Four - who were all 31-or-younger when they got their first head coaching job - will help push more athletic directors to do the same, to take a chance, to worry less about what somebody's done and more about what somebody's built to do.