That land has been fought over and stole away from people so many times that I don't think it matters anymore. Since you can't get from somebody that has a false title to something, (meaning if somebody stole something away and you gained it from them it still wouldn't be yours but the person that originally had it even if you thought you gained it rightfully from the person that stole it.) and even Islam tends to believe, that then it could be argued it should go back to the oldest reasonably cohesive people that had a claim to it at one time, which is probably the Israelis. They existed before Islam was even a religion, and it's not like they offered to give it back to them when the Romans were finally taken down in that area instead of taking it for themselves. Of course the Israelis did basically the same thing to the Palestinians at a later time that's why I say it doesn’t really matter in any practical manner anymore. You can't go back nearly a century, or centuries, or even millennia to make your argument. The best that can be hoped for is to work out peace among yourselves now, just as I'm sure nobody in the US, no matter what there view on Israel, is going to give their land back to the Native Americans any time soon or Northern Ireland is going to just be given back to Ireland and all the protestants kicked out, or any number of countless other examples across the world where one people got kicked out and another moved in. If that was the case pretty much every single person in the world would have somebody in there past that took something from somebody else and would owe them. At some point it becomes ridiculous. After so much time one has to except that what is done is done and fighting about things only your ancestors but you never had and that happened before you were even born is pretty stupid. All that can be hoped for is to have everybody get along, treat each other the right way, and reasonable share what both of you have now.