Who has Been the Better Basketball Player, Kobe Bryant or Shaquille O'Neal?

Who has Been the Better Basketball Player?

  • Kobe Bryant

    Votes: 31 62.0%
  • Shaquille O'Neal

    Votes: 19 38.0%

  • Total voters
    50
...of which he was innocent.

Indeed. I figure we all should know that by now, and if not, well, get the hell out of this thread.
 

roronoa3000

Banned
What the fuck kind of question is this? Even in 2008 this wasn't a legit question. Kobe was a better basketball player than Snaq in high school.

Kobe is on pace to break the most points in an NBA career record. He'll most certainly be top 3 when he retires.

He also has...

5 NBA championships.
2 NBA Finals MVP
1 Regular Season MVP (Should be at least 2. How can you average 35 points and not get MVP??)
12 time All Star
10 time defensive all NBA. (ya he's one of the best perimeter and 1-1 defenders of all time)
12 time all NBA.
2 time Scoring Champion. (ya he's one of the greatest offensive threats of all time)

I know this thread is 2 years old, but to compare one of the top 5 greatest players in the history of the game to Snaq?? is fucking laughable.

Snaq did NOT lead 3 teams to the NBA finals. He led 2, and piggy backed Wade and the refs to a 3rd. He was the main guy in L.A, but he wouldn't have won without Kobe. He wouldn't have even made it to 3 straight Finals without Kobe.

Even if you go position wise, Kobe is only eclipsed by MJ. Snaq isn't even the greatest center of all time. Not even top 3.

And for the record, Kobe did not run Snaq out of town. Snaq became a fat fuck and Buss wasn't going to give some out of shape piece of shit, a max, long term contract extension. It worked out didn't it? L.A is racking up championships while that fat fuck wanders from team to team trying to stay relevant. Fuck Snaq.

Go Lakers!

Bullshit!! I demand facts!! :mad:


P.S. Facts prove nothing!!!:mad:
 
This is a common misconception. Snaq does not care about winning. If he did, he'd stay in shape. He cares about entertaining. That's why he does more dancing and rapping than actual balling anymore.

Kobe cares about greatness. He's the fiercest competitor since MJ. How can you say he doesn't care about winning? He demanded to play in L.A before he ever stepped foot on a basketball court. Why? Because he wanted to win. He trains every off season, stepping up his game to new levels while everybody else is satisfied with their game. Why? Because he wants to win. He forced front office to make moves or he was leaving town. Why? Because he wants to win.

People just hate Kobe for whatever reason. It's all good though. Ya'll can take Snaq "every single time". You'll get bounced in the 2nd round (if you're lucky enough to make the playoffs). Kobe's winning titles now and cementing his legacy as an all time great while Snaq is trying to MC in some shitty club.

Shaq has proven all he needs to prove. At this point, he is pretty old, so you can't really blame him for being slower than he used to be. He's a big man too, so age probably takes it's toll even sooner.

I will give you that Kobe wants to win, but you can tell that his only reason for that is to prove how great he thinks he is. Is he a good player? Absolutely. Is he as good as Jordan? No way.

As for who is better between Shaq or Kobe, it's hard to compare them because they play different positions. One thing I do know is that if I were the GM of an NBA team and had the choice of drafting either one of them, I would definitely take Shaq. He gives me the better chance to win in my opinion.
 
Shaq has proven all he needs to prove. At this point, he is pretty old, so you can't really blame him for being slower than he used to be. He's a big man too, so age probably takes it's toll even sooner.

I will give you that Kobe wants to win, but you can tell that his only reason for that is to prove how great he thinks he is. Is he a good player? Absolutely. Is he as good as Jordan? No way.

As for who is better between Shaq or Kobe, it's hard to compare them because they play different positions. One thing I do know is that if I were the GM of an NBA team and had the choice of drafting either one of them, I would definitely take Shaq. He gives me the better chance to win in my opinion.

I never said he was better than Jordan. Just Shaq.

Fair enough. If you took Shaq 1st overall, I'd gladly take Kobe 2nd.
 
how many people yell Shaq right before 'shooting' any given object into any given receptacle? that's what i thought...
 
I'll take Shaq every single time. Shaq cared about winning. Kobe only cares about Kobe.

Wait, what? You mean Shaq, the one who's more concerned with his own fame, likeability, and legacy, cares more than Kobe, who is only the fiercest competitor there is?

Oh, and btw, screw Shaq, his leaving the Magic cost us at least 1 title.
 

mrzbone

Banned
definitely michael jordan, kobe is so arrogant n not playin fair, when he know he will lose the ball he is trying to get a faul
shaq was big n strong but less talent
there is one good player n he is michael jordan, the best
 
Wait, what? You mean Shaq, the one who's more concerned with his own fame, likeability, and legacy, cares more than Kobe, who is only the fiercest competitor there is?

Oh, and btw, screw Shaq, his leaving the Magic cost us at least 1 title.

Yeah, I mean Shaq. The guy whose coming there in the first place got you a title you never would have gotten otherwise.

The one I'm not talking about is Kobe. The guy who, out of jealousy, got Shaq traded away from the Lakers so he could finally be the center of attention in L.A. I'm sorry, but I don't care how much Kobe claims to care. When you tear apart a team that won three titles, and get rid of the #1 guy just for the sake of your own ego, the whole "fiercest competitor" claim doesn't ring true. If he is such a fierce competitor, he should have been fighting to conquer his ego, and continued riding Shaq's coat tails to more rings. Who cares if he was number two as long as the TEAM was winning? Kobe claims to be all about winning, but it's only as long as HE is the one getting all the acolades for it.

Kobe's backstabbing move to get Shaq traded is equal in my mind to the punk behavior of Stephon Marbury when he demanded a trade from the Timberwolves because he admittedly couldn't handle being the #2 star and being the second highest paid player on the team. He got to go to a team where he was the big man on campus, but how many rings has he won? Had he stayed in Minnesota with KG, they would have probably won a few championships. Like Kobe, it's all about me, me, me, me....

Back on the subject of Kobe, the guy even looks like a rat. Pointy nose, beaty eyes, long head, and an overall sneaky expression. Sometimes you CAN judge a book by it's cover.
 
If the Wolves would've got Shaq in '93 that whole franchise would be a different story. Magic sucked balls before Shaq came there and made them relavent. Kobe can suck a pair of sweaty, smelly balls for all I care. :thefinger
 
Shaq was classy enough to say things that saved his team from a big, distracting scandal, but everyone knows Kobe was the problem child and the reason for Shaq leaving.

You can think that C4TB but Shaq treated Kobe the same way he treated Anfernee Hardaway. He talked shit on the guy up and down while in Orlando and after he left. No different from how he did Kobe...I've met Shaq...even hung with the guy in some social settings and as affable a character as he is...the guy doesn't like sharing the spot light.
 

Skyraider22

The One and Only Big Daddy
Oh that is a really hard one.They were so good together for so long but as of right now it is Shaq.more years played but Kobe will be one of the best and I think will surpass him and a lot more.
 
Top