Which QB would you take

[STDiva]

I think that fact the Big Ben's ability to keep the pay alive is both a gift and a curse.

Manning has the system build around him and it's a hell of a system, but once pressure gets to him he really can't keep plays alive

Brady, well i can't stand him.

Brees is actually the only QB out of the 2005 draft class not to win a Super Bowl. his time willcome.

Brees was drafted in 2001. Same year as Vick. The 2005 class is Alex Smith, Aaron Rodgers and Jason Campbell. Are you referring to Rivers, and the 2004 class with Big Ben and Eli? J.P Losman was also in that class, drafted in the 1st round.

 

[jasonk282]

Brees was drafted in 2001. Same year as Vick. The 2005 class is Alex Smith, Aaron Rodgers and Jason Campbell. Are you referring to Rivers, and the 2004 class with Big Ben and Eli? J.P Losman was also in that class, drafted in the 1st round.

Yes I was unsure of the year sorry. It was the 2005 season that's where I got confused.

 

[Neutron66]

The fact that Matt Cassel took over for the Patriots last year, got 11 wins and had 23 TD's shows that Brady isn't so special after all. A guy that hadn't started a game since high school took over and looked damn good doing it. 2 consecutive 400 yard games. I don't think Brady even has 1.

If Peyton went down, the Colts are a 4-5 win team.

Who's Peytons backup? I bet you don't know. Just like you didn't know who Bradys backup was until he came in last season.

Peytons backup might turn out to be better than he is.

You don't know.

 

[lachemo]

i'll take a qb chick in a tight uniform with her titties bulging out while she calls signals. That should distract the defense enough to allow me to run a screen play.

lmao

 

[averageJoe]

Either of the Manning brothers are awesome!

 

[The Grasshopper]

Tom Brady is due for another ring.


When Tom Brady stepped onto the scene he remind me of Joe Montana, two cool cats who have that NFL Big Game Domination thing down pat. Rings... I never thought Peyton would get one, like Marino but he did. Out of the Mannings I think Eli has the potential for more championships actually. :thumbsup:


*edit* Championship-wise I'd take Ben Rothlisberger over Peyton, I doubt Peyton will win another but who know's? :dunno:

 

[bennihanna]

i'll go for a Mr. Brett Favre

 

[STDiva]

Who's Peytons backup? I bet you don't know. Just like you didn't know who Bradys backup was until he came in last season.

Peytons backup might turn out to be better than he is.

You don't know.

Sorgi. And I didn't have to look it up. He actually gets playing time. Unlike Brady's backups because Belichick is too busy running up the score.

 

[BDwestcoast]

Big Ben is the only one with the most significant comeback win now.

 

[The Grasshopper]

Peyton Manning, but 5 years from now..... Sam Bradford.

I know, I'm annoying.

you know, i think i may agree on bradford....

 

[jakeballs77]

Can I still pick Joe Montana? I haven't followed the NFL for years