Which QB would you take
- Thread starter jasonk282
- Start date
Ace Bandage
The one and only.
Ugh, you're making me choose between my two favorite QBs. That's not fair. 
Peyton plays for my Indianapolis Colts, but I saw every single snap Drew Brees took at Ross-Ade Stadium during his college days with the Boilermakers. Those were our glory days, and I never realized how great Brees was until he was gone. So my heart says go with Brees, but my head tells me that nobody is better than Peyton when it comes to the two minute drill. I want the ball in his hands every time. Nobody orchestrates the two minute drill like #18.
And oh yeah, fuck Tom Brady. I fuckin' hate the Patriots! :hatsoff:
Peyton plays for my Indianapolis Colts, but I saw every single snap Drew Brees took at Ross-Ade Stadium during his college days with the Boilermakers. Those were our glory days, and I never realized how great Brees was until he was gone. So my heart says go with Brees, but my head tells me that nobody is better than Peyton when it comes to the two minute drill. I want the ball in his hands every time. Nobody orchestrates the two minute drill like #18. And oh yeah, fuck Tom Brady. I fuckin' hate the Patriots! :hatsoff:
jasonk282
Banned
Assuming it's happening as of how good they are today, with today's rules, they all got equal personnel to work with, they are playing equal defenses, all the circumstances are the same for all of them, and I have to pick based on who gives my team the best chance to win, I would go with Manning.
Badabingo.
Tom Brady no question. It's really not that close. I'd go with Manning second. I really think Big Ben is overrated and the Steel Curtain won him his SBs.
Not to mention, Gisele pretty much selected Brady above all other GLOBAL CELEBRITIES to bang....:bowdown: Giselle knows best...:dunno::thefinger
What difference does it make? All are great QB's,but wouldn't be shit without the team around them.You could probably interchange each QB onto each other's teams and you would get the same results,because the teams that they play for are good.
If you had Breese,Manning,or Ben on any of the Patriot Superbowl teams,the results would more than likely be the same and they would all have multiple rings.
On the flip side,if you put ANY of those guys on say,The Raiders,or Rams,they would look just as bad as those QBs do right now.
If you had Breese,Manning,or Ben on any of the Patriot Superbowl teams,the results would more than likely be the same and they would all have multiple rings.
On the flip side,if you put ANY of those guys on say,The Raiders,or Rams,they would look just as bad as those QBs do right now.
I'll take Manning behind me and Brady in front.
damn, you know that's a sandwich you'd like to get into...
damn, you know that's a sandwich you'd like to get into...
meganmilian
Banned
I used to think Brady, but he is a little suspect. I would have to fo with my cutie lil Brees, but what is that damn thing on his face. It looks like it is alive. He's got COUSIN IT on his face probably telling him who to throw to. LMAO!:2 cents:
I highly doubt that. If Manning or Brady where the qb for the Raiders this season they would be significantly better. I can easily see the Raiders go 8-8 with either of those two, considering a lot of the rest of the Raiders other than the QBs aren't that bad. With better coaching you could even add a game or two to that. I would also say it's not the system that makes Manning or Brady look good it's having them that makes the system seem a lot better than what it is. I also think if you took somebody like Manning and replaced him with an avarage quarterback the Colts would struggle to win half their games each year.
Superbowl wins has to be one of the worst criteria to judge somebody’s individual skill by. In any case why should somebody get individual acclimation for a team accomplishment. Tom Brady hasn't won three Superbowls. The 53 members of the New England Patriots, plus coaching staff, plus scouting department, plus front office, plus miscellaneous support personel, plus ownership have won those Superbowls.
So says the Dandy Marino fan...:thefinger:dunno:
A super bowl win --singular--might be an indicator of overatedness.
But Super Bowl WINS---plural--sorry, that's legend making. What else is there to judge greatness? Simple stat analysis in not enough....
StanScratch
My Penis Is Dancing!
Trapper John was a hell of a QB...made a very unusual call for the last play of the game that helped the good doctors win.
After that, I guess I would go with Ryan Leaf.
After that, I guess I would go with Ryan Leaf.
Manning all the way. :bowdown:
