so would you enjoy watching an action movie in which the actors has realistic prop guns or would it be just as acceptable for them to use super soakers? would you watch a medieval themed movie in which the actors used tree branches for their fight scenes or would realistic swords be better? would it matter if they used a rusted out 1982 subaru wagon in a movie about street racing or would a real sports car be preferable?
edit: btw i'm very secure with my sexuality, naked dudes and homosexuality doesn't make me uncomfortable or queesy. i don't want to fuck men and i'm not aroused by men but i can appreciate a handsome looking guy over a haggard fucker and would much prefer to look at the former naked as well
:2 cents:
I'm not sure those are great analogies. I watch action movies for the realistic action, so they have to have guns, etc...the one that I can say that I wouldn't mind from your examples though is the rusty car one...if it's well done, who cares if a chase involves a maserati or a ford focus?
But porn is different. I'm watching the movie to see a hot broad get put through the paces, not for realistic sex. As long as the guy can keep a hard-on and pound the chick, who cares what he looks like?
In some ways, I prefer he be not-so-great. Makes the girl more attainable and slutty (i.e. "She'll fuck anybody!")