The All Star Game is supposed to showcase the best, not the most popular. The Canadiens fans ruined it this year, even if it is only the starting lineup. The only players that deserve to be on the starting lineup in the east is Crosby, Malkin and maybe Price. And not to mention that any All Star starting lineup without Ovechkin is a joke.
Don't blame the Canadiens fans ENTIRELY in this case. The game is in Montreal and the fans wanted to see their hometown stars in the game. You can't blame them for voting more than anyone else. Not that it would've changed things, but the NHL screwed up badly by not putting the right guys on the ballot. I know it's hard to predict how well rookies and sophomores are going to play, but look at some of the guys who weren't on the ballot: Devin Setoguchi, David Krejci, Phil Kessel, Jeff Carter(hello, leads the league in goals and he's not on the ballot!?!?!?!). Not to mention Tim Thomas, who has arguably been the best goalie in the NHL thus far. I wrote in Thomas every time I voted and I wrote in Carter every time as well.
Here's what the lineups should've been: West: Forwards: Jarome Iginla, Patrick Kane, Ryan Getzlaf. Toews doesn't deserve it, but Getzlaf and Kane were fine choices. Iginla is tied for the lead in points in the West. Defence: Brian Campbell and Dan Boyle. Niedermayer is having a good season, but there are at least a half dozen Western D-men who are more deserving. Goalie: Evgeni Nabokov. Giguere is nowhere near deserving.
Other notable West D-men: Shea Weber, Sheldon Souray, Brian Rafalski, Nicklas Lidstrom, Rob Blake. Other notable forwards: Joe Thornton, Pavel Datsyuk, Patrick Marleau, Daniel Sedin, Rick Nash, Shane Doan, Devin Setoguchi, Marian Hossa, Mikko Koivu. Goalies: Mikka Kiprusoff, Steve Mason, Niklas Backstrom.
East: Fowards: Evgeni Malkin, Alex Ovechkin, Zach Parise. Kovalev isn't quite all-star calibre this year and Crosby is, and always has been, wildly overrated. D-men: Mark Streit, Andrei Markov. I love what Komisarek is and does, but he has missed many games. Goalie: Tim Thomas. Price is a close second.
Other notable East forwards: Sidney Crosby, Marc Savard, Nicklas Backstrom, Jeff Carter, Patrik Elias, Mike Richards, David Krejci, Phil Kessel, Simon Gagne. D-men: Mike Green, Dennis Wideman, Zdeno Chara. Goalies: Carey Price, Henrik Lundqvist, Ryan Miller, Scott Clemmensen, Manny Fernandez.