Yeah, silly Denver. They acquired arguably the greatest QB in NFL history, the only 4-time NFL MVP, a former Super Bowl MVP winner, a man who ranks second or third in every major passing statistical category. Peyton has been a pillar of the community, the face of Indianapolis and the Colts franchise, and a man who has his own children's hospital. And he won't just be regular Peyton this year. He'll be angry Peyton. Eager to prove that he can still play at the highest level. A man who will be more focused on winning than ever before in his career. When the Broncos make the playoffs this year it will be because of their QB and not in spite of him.
Tim Tebow is mediocre on his best day. He's more well know for praying on the field to invisible deities than he is for his prowess and performance on the football field. He's a marketing tool. Tebow is lucky to even be in the league. He'll never be successful in the NFL. He seems like a great guy off the field, but he just doesn't have the tools to compete in this league.
Peyton Manning was a great quarterback, but the problem is that nobody knows if he will be able to hold up. He has had four neck operations, and that's not good when you play a sport as violent as NFL football. He may or may not be able to play at the level he used to.
Regarding Tim Tebow, just tell the Steelers how mediocre he is. He sliced and diced them up in the playoffs last year. Also, don't try to tell anyone that Tebow didn't play a big part in Denver's playoff appearance last year. They went 1-4 with Kyle Orton under center, and it was Tebow who got them back on track through tough play and great leadership. The defense certainly deserves credit for their success as well, but as I said, the same defense went 1-4 before Tebow was inserted in the line up on offense.
Furthermore, the 2011 season was Tebow's first year as a starter. How did Terry Bradshaw and Troy Aikman do in their first year as a starter? They are both in the Hall of Fame now, and neither one of them can touch Tebow when it comes to leadership and other intangibles. If I were building a franchise I would take Tebow over either one of them.