I'm pretty much a pussy when it comes to experimental eating. The weirdest things I eat are peanut butter and onion sandwiches or mayo in mashed potatoes.
OMG! You gotta try a peanut butter and pickle sandwich sometime. It sounds weird, I know, but seriously... try it. It's so good! Dill pickles, not sweet pickles.
As for my reply to the thread. I don't really eat anything weird, my tastes are way too conservative- I would never eat lamb, duck, veal, eel, frog legs, squid, octopus, bugs, etc. The closest thing to weird (other than peanut butter and pickles) that I've ever eaten is something that is only local to my home, it can't be found anywhere else in the USA or around the world, it's local, made in the smack dab center of Pennsylvania, called Miller's Hot Bologna. It's fucking amazing! It's basically pickled bologna with hot spices, sliced up long ways. Of course like all bologna, the ingredients are disgusting, including tongue, tail, cheek, intestines, etc. After I read the label once when I was a kid I swore off eating them for a couple years, but I couldn't hold out eating them too long... they're so amazing! Best bologna ever. You can even order it online, I actually just found that out prior to posting in this thread, so I'm gonna have to order me some of that! I miss it.
Here's a pic and link to where you can find it. Trust me, if you try this, you will not be disappointed! So fucking good. I could sit and eat the entire jar in one sitting.
http://www.blaircandy.com/hotbologna28oz.html