First Wave: Expiration of 2001 and 2003 Tax Relief
In 2001 and 2003, the GOP Congress enacted several tax cuts for investors, small business owners, and families. These will all expire on January 1, 2011:
I guess I'm a bit confused on what some here are complaining about. The Tax Relief Acts of 2001 and 2003 were written (by Republicans) with
sunset provisions. Do some here not understand what "sunset" means? This reminds me of the homeowners who got balloon mortgages and then complained once the payoff date was looming. What did they think was going to happen? Humans are amusing creatures with short memories. Maybe when I retire I'll get one and keep it as a pet in the backyard. I'll move his food dish everyday and see if he can remember where I put it the next day. And if he can't find it, I guess he'll claim that I'm trying to starve him.
Something else that confuses me is that I see some of the same people who typically complain about the deficit complaining about this issue... which ADDS to the deficit. While I agree that a lower tax environment is healthier for business than a higher tax environment, the Bush/GOP tax cuts were too small and not targeted well enough to really spur economic growth (in true Supply Side fashion), yet they did contribute greatly to the deficit. There were not corresponding spending cuts, and so there was actually something of a double whammy: higher spending and less revenue = surplus gone and deficit swells.
My feeling is that ALL portions of the act that apply to the middle class should be left in place. Those portions that deal with business investment in plant & equipment should be left in place - in fact, I think they should add more incentives for businesses to expand or update equipment. There are parts of the act that do have merits, especially in a time of weak recovery and high unemployment. The problem I have with the GOP (and their apologists) on this issue is that unless ALL parts of the act are left in place, they are content to let ALL of it expire... and then they'll have something else to whine about. Apparently adding to the deficit doesn't bother them as much as they like to pretend it does. Here is a chance for the GOP to prove to me that within that party there is still a belief in fiscal responsibility and an understanding of how Supply Side economics is supposed to work. Thus far, they have failed.
Something else I have to mention: when I hear people say that "they would start a business, but the tax rate is too high", all I can do is
When I started my real estate business, I was borrowing money at 12%+ and marginal tax rates were higher than they are now. Reagan got rid of accelerated depreciation on income producing real estate and most fully assumable mortgage options went away. But I continued buying and I continued making money. Not to toot my own horn, but I developed a solid business plan and I followed it. My business plan did not depend on taxes being at any particular level.
Anyone who tells you that the success of their business plan hinges on a marginal tax rate being at X rather than Y is full of shit and is just a failure waiting to happen. If people now can't make money (in whatever business) with interest rates at 5% and taxes at 35%
or 39.6% (
once they get to that highest bracket), then my feeling is they are incapable of running a successful business to begin with. It's like that girl with the squeaky voice that used to be on Saturday Night Live years ago... Victoria something. She was on Fox Business News last year. She said that if taxes went up, she had no motivation to work anymore. That ditz hasn't been in a movie in over a decade, as far as I know. And once she got booted off SNL, the only movies she was ever in were low budget C/D movies that went straight to VHS/DVD. The (real) reason she isn't motivated to work is because no one will hire her. Some people like to use red herrings to explain their failures. They're meant to fail. The entertainment value is in watching them dream up excuses as to why they failed.
If the GOP really cares, they'll work with the Dems to save the parts of the Tax Relief Act that have merits and ditch those portions that do nothing more than add to the deficit. The Dems have not exectuted very well thus far and the way it looks, the GOP's only idea is to say "no" to whatever idea the Dems have. IMO, we are going to be in even deeper shit going forward, as neither side is able to accomplish anything meaningful.