As a girl it is weird looking in on a discussion like this between guys about their penises. Some of you are getting very up tight about it.
I am not hugely experienced in handling thousands of cocks but for what it is worth from my point of view being circumcised or not does not matter once it is clean. Other girls might feel differently about it but it is how I think about it.
I did some reading about it on the web a few months ago and I read as some others have said that circumcised men loose some sensation. I cannot remember which sites I read it on but it was in more than one place and they were proper sex education type sites so I guess this is not just a myth. So from the guys point of view maybe it is better if he is not circumcised and from my point of view if a guy is putting his penis into my body - whether vagina, mouth, anus or wherever, I would like to think that he is able to feel it to the fullest possible extent.
If some guys prefer to have their penis circumcised then let them do it, if some do not that is OK. Do you have to slag each other off over it?
The one thing I do not like is the idea of circumcising babies. Where I come from (Ireland) it is not done except for those who have religious reasons for doing it. I do not think people should be allowed to do something like this to a child. Wait until they are older and they can decide for themselves.
With any surgery there is always some risk, even a very, very small one.