Homeschool is the only answer for those who love their children.
No one has the right to tell you what to do with your child. You and you alone are responsible for your child.
If it's against your values, and it should be, to send your children off to a state school then that is fine.
You aren't looking at the wider implications here, removing all of the other factors that make this a bad idea and looking solely at the economic set up of society in regards to education then the gap between rich and poor that we already see, both economically and in education is going to widen ever more.
If a person is rich and well educated (through private schools or home tutors or whatever) then home schooling is an option because the have the means to see it through properly. Giving their children all of the options to gain knowledge and understanding at their own pace.
But what of the poor in this situation? Those who have (for example) to work two jobs each just to pay the rent, and put food on the table, what of these people? Who weren't born into wealth and good educational prospects who have no other option that to work remedial jobs to gain the income they need. Of course they love their children just as much as the family who are slightly better off than they are but trying to keep a roof over their heads and food on the table takes up enough of their time - mainly because it takes up
ALL of their time. Having to have to teach their children as well (even if they want to) is just not an option. The way society is set up it would be impossible to do.
So lets say this is the case; what would we be left with if home schooling were the "only option if parents loved their children"? We would be left with wealthy, well educated children who will grow up always being wealthy and well educated and poor, poorly educated children who'll always stay this way. This is not how it should work in a civilised society. This scenario is more akin to the 18th century than it is to the 21st.
Every child should have the opportunity to a decent education and public schools no matter what faults they might have (and there are many) allow this to take place.
Mr Romeike, an evangelical Christian, said he believes the German curriculum is "against Christian values".
Nothing more really needs to be said about that. The quote says it all.