C.K. Lawrence
Closed Account
I think it'd be tough for him to cut my top 8 in honesty if those guys have the years they could. I meant to add Rivers myself but decided against it. 
Your top 10 NFL quarterbacks
- Thread starter Chrism86354
- Start date
First off, there's no way I'm putting anyone in their first and second year in my top 10. That shit is asinine. That said, my list is...
1. Drew Brees
2. Tom Brady
3. Aaron Rodgers
4. Peyton Manning
5. Ben Roethlisberger
6. Phillip Rivers
7. Jay Cutler
8. Eli Manning
9. Matt Ryan
10. Tony Romo
1. Drew Brees
2. Tom Brady
3. Aaron Rodgers
4. Peyton Manning
5. Ben Roethlisberger
6. Phillip Rivers
7. Jay Cutler
8. Eli Manning
9. Matt Ryan
10. Tony Romo
You are my new favorite person in the entire world.
BAYAMONXXX
Land Of The Snakes
How you not going to have Stafford on that list? He has one of only 5 5,000 yard seasons in NFL history (and only one of 4 people to do it). Not including him is asinine
So my team has Sanchez and Tebow.
What next?
What next?
:clap:
What did Newton win?
...and given 15 more games, Matt Flynn would've passed for 6000 yards plus!
Yes Matthew had a fantastic season... but it was just one, and in this NFL, I can't tell if 5000 passing yard QB's are gonna start being the norm. I need to see him do this more than one season. I would place him in the top 15 on that potential, but my top 10 play well more consistently.
Offensive rookie of the year
Assuming he would have been allowed to play that horrid Lions D for 15 more games...put him against San Fran or Baltimore and he'll look like Mark Sanchez
OROY was Andy Dalton's Award and anybody that watches football knows it.
The same as Cutler. Not much.
Let's not act like Newton is anywhere near Cutler's caliber of QB? I'll give him the edge on rushing, but... let's not go there.
Who's acting?
Cutler is not an elite QB...Id take Stafford or Cam over him all day every day. Both are at his level already and are younger with a lot more promise. I dont think anyone, including Bears fans who were honest with themselves, wouldnt trade Cutler for either one of them straight up
Cutler's BEST at each offensive stat in his career
TD - 27 (2009)
INT (low in full season) - 14 (2007)
QB Rating (full season) - 88.1 (2007)
AVG - 7.48 (2010)
COMP % - 63.6 % (2007) - note his cmp % has gone down every season
YARDS - 4526 (2008) - none over 3700 outside this one
compare it to Stafford's one full season
TD - 41
INT - 16
QB Rating - 97.2
AVG - 7.6
COMP % - 63.5 %
YARDS - 5038
Staffords one season blows a hypothetical season of all Cutler's best stats from different seasons out of the water. Cutler is a poor mans Stafford
Cutler's BEST at each offensive stat in his career
TD - 27 (2009)
INT (low in full season) - 14 (2007)
QB Rating (full season) - 88.1 (2007)
AVG - 7.48 (2010)
COMP % - 63.6 % (2007) - note his cmp % has gone down every season
YARDS - 4526 (2008) - none over 3700 outside this one
compare it to Stafford's one full season
TD - 41
INT - 16
QB Rating - 97.2
AVG - 7.6
COMP % - 63.5 %
YARDS - 5038
Staffords one season blows a hypothetical season of all Cutler's best stats from different seasons out of the water. Cutler is a poor mans Stafford
Consider the fact that Cutler has top 5 worst O-Line and receiving core, and still keeps this team in the playoffs, averages 26 pts a game as a starter (more than Newton and Stafford), and had fewer red zone picks than both last year. Both Stafford and Newton boast Pro Bowl recievers, while the Bears haven't had one since Marty Booker.
Again, take nothing away from both guys, they had good seasons, BUT IT WAS ONE SEASON!!!
Similar threads
[NEEDS ID]
These girls plz :-)
