"Woman" sues Catholic hospital for . . .

Facetious

Moderated
Transgender Woman Sues Catholic Hospital for Refusing Breast Enlargement Surgery

Thursday , January 10, 2008

A transgender woman who claims a hospital refused to allow her breast enlargement surgery because it wasn't "God's will" is suing a Catholic hospital, according to a report.

Charlene Hastings, 57, who has already had one major surgery to become a woman claims Seton Medical Center denied her request because she had a sex-change operation.

Cont'd

Nice people ! . . . . the trans:wtf:
 

Torre82

Moderator \ Jannie
Staff member
A hospital refusing money? That's just wrong.

Refusing because of religion/sexual identity? Oy. Discrimination, cut 'n dry. Fast forward to the million dollar award and free surgery at alternative hospital.
 
I'm guessing that the "one major surgery" that he already had was to get rid of the twig and berries. Why not just do the boob job? The major part was already done. And why doesn't she just go to the hospital as the first op? They are sooooooo getting sued.

Some people would give their right nut for the kind of money she'll make off this. Pun very intended.
 

tartanterrier

Is somewhere outhere.
He probably never had much to get cut off in the 1st place.I guess he can't afford the boob job so by suing them he'll get the money for it.I wonder if he'll go back to the same hospital :D
 
A hospital refusing money? That's just wrong.

Refusing because of religion/sexual identity? Oy. Discrimination, cut 'n dry. Fast forward to the million dollar award and free surgery at alternative hospital.

I think that only applies to emergent medical care, not elective surgeries. Religious entities are permitted to discriminate based on religious ideology, sadly.
 
I don't know if it's a private hospital or not (I didn't read the article), but most of them can refuse a lot of things that a publicly funded hospital can't.
 
I think that only applies to emergent medical care, not elective surgeries. Religious entities are permitted to discriminate based on religious ideology, sadly.

I don't know if it's a private hospital or not (I didn't read the article), but most of them can refuse a lot of things that a publicly funded hospital can't.


You have to click the link in the link to get to the full story,here is part.
http://www.insidebayarea.com/search...h-www.insidebayarea.com-www.insidebayarea.com

When it was owned by Catholic Healthcare West, a large hospital conglomerate, Seton apparently did allow transgender surgery.

But when the Daughters of Charity, which took ownership of the hospital in 2002, learned in 2006 that such surgeries were still taking place, they were stopped, said two sources who asked not to be identified because they were not authorized to speak publicly for their organizations.

Wertz thinks Seton's policy violates the Unruh Act, a state law that prohibits discrimination on the basis of gender, gender identity or sexual orientation.

"There's simply no religious exemption in the Unruh Act," Wertz said. "We're talking about a type of care that's OK for one class but not another."

While her case winds through the courts, Hastings said she has put off having the breast augmentation surgery, in part because her breasts are continuing to grow through hormone therapy.

However, she is planning to have surgery to feminize her nose in February. Hastings, who works for the city of San Francisco as a tax collector, said she was raised Catholic. "I think God loves me no matter what," she said."

Reading that it says basically if you do something for someone you have to do it for anyone.Yeah they can not do abortions I guess on religious grounds but breast augmentation I'm sure is something they allow so the law says they can't discriminate.Guy wants bigger boobs the idea may not be their cup of tea but I think they will lose the case.
 

Facetious

Moderated
However, she is planning to have surgery to feminize her nose in February. Hastings, who works for the city of San Francisco as a tax collector

Yea, If there's any tax base left living in that mysterious, childless city.

I may be able to pull just a smidge of compassion out of my gut for this individual if only this individual was . . . . ummmm . . uhhh 23 - 29 . . he!!, up to 45 years of age, but if you haven't found dignity by said individuals' age, ya might as well hunk it off the Golden Gate.

I think that it's selfish and narcissistic to pull that kind of crap. Just think about how many abandoned aminals that these funds could serve. Protect some innocent lives for a change ! Pleease ! :angels: ;)
 

Torre82

Moderator \ Jannie
Staff member
"ALL" U.S. Catholic hospitals do not allow any abortion procedures !

Instead, they call the procedures "therapeutic D & C" Dilatation and Currettage !

"A rose by any other name"
 
A hospital refusing money? That's just wrong.

Refusing because of religion/sexual identity? Oy. Discrimination, cut 'n dry. Fast forward to the million dollar award and free surgery at alternative hospital.

no never! hospitals never refuse money! :p
 
Top