1.Have to disagree for the fact that there are hockey players that are the same size as linebackers,plus the fact that they are hitting you with way more impact that you will ever get hit in football.don't know about you,but I would rather get hit by Ray Lewis running full speed than Zdeno Chara skating full speed.
Hockey also has more games than football,so those guys take way more punishment than football players.
Like I said before,with a salary cap in a sport,everyone is on the same playing field as far as "buying" a championship,so every team has a legitimate shot on day one to actually win.In baseball,there are no illusions of the teams that have no shot of winning.Just ask Pirate fans for the last 16 some odd years.
1. On every play in football the objective of the defense is to stop a player. In hockey the defensive objective is to stop a puck. It would stand to reason then how football would be a more physical sport by nature of the objective.
The range of players who are attempting to stop the player with the ball in football goes anywhere from high 100 lbs. to 3 or 4 hundred pounds. Where is the 300 or 400 lb. hockey player?
2. Hockey is a physical game but if it was anywhere near as physical play in and play out there is no way they could play that many games. There is checking in hockey but that is a tactic in hockey...not the objective.
3. That's just the hitting part. It undoubtedly takes skill and stamina to skate..but I doubt it's as physically challenging to skate as it is to actually use the brute strength of your muscles to get you from one speed on a football field to another, change directions and expose your limbs/joints to twists, jarring and impact.
It is much more of a challenge to stay healthy short term and long term in football than hockey IMO. Without taking anything away from hockey as I know how some feel but I don't even see the debate on that one.
Go to youth ube and find some vids of great hits in hockey and then some of the great hits in football....I think the football hits will certainly be more violent...in some cases helmet to helmet, helmet to sternum, etc. Considering the average weight of a bowling ball can weigh what about what a football player's head and helmet weigh...that can be like taking a bowling ball in the chest or against your head.