That's true, but then again a lot of that is from all the mediocre years he stayed around and padded his stats following the years where he was on his way to being one of the top ten players ever to play the game. His peek years were pretty much done when he went to Cincinnati, and his time before that is what the vast part of what is going to get him in the Hall of Fame is going to be based on. Now he's probably top a top 50 all time person. That's nothing to sneeze at to be sure, and it's quite an accomplishment, but when compared to somebody like Bonds who is probably either the best or second best player ever you can see how he fell off from what he was, especially when those two were compared so often in the first half of their careers. (Of course all of that is ignoring the steroid issue. Then again we have no idea if Griffy did any either.)