i don't mind a thin girl with an ass, but i prefer a thick or 'chubby' girl (though i don't think of them as chubby, i think of them as normal), and sometimes i really like a big girl. case in point; peaches larue, or bbwsophiarose (sophia rose).
most of these guys will never get that hot girl they are talking about anyway... so what does it matter?
It's never really been about "fat" v. "skinny" with me. I just want a hourglass, and the wider the better. It's just so damn hard to find a wide hardbody, but they do exist. Most of the time I have to go for softer curves to get what I want, although I don't go for the majority of BBWs, only FFWs and those rare hardbodies.
As a bonus, the wider the figure, the wider the chest and, typically, the more resulting bust. It's that little symmetry with the hips that does it all for me. So the more the wide hips fang and the wide tits hang, the more my spear wants to bang.
No one is going to tell me that Shay Laren (thinner hourglass) is more beautiful than Karina Hart (fuller hourglass) or that Karina Hart is more beautiful than Maria Moore (BBW hourglass), simply because one is thinner than the other. To me, it's all the same perfection in different proportions. And I'm not going to try to pick one over the other.