I’m sorry to have to bring you the bad news but your argument doesn't
hold water.
My viewpoint is based on hard FACTS.
Valuev was given 12 rounds that’s 36 minutes to land this amazing single
punch you talk so much about and he failed to do it. FACT!!
The rules are you must outscore or knockout your opponent within the
allotted time. He failed. FACT!!
At the end of the day a man’s weight is just a number. It does not tell
you how hard they can punch. FACT!!
Having a harder punch means nothing unless you can land it. FACT!!
What makes you think he could knock
out Valuev with a broken hand?
I answered this question in my previous reply with yet another FACT!!
I’ll repeat what I said for you with a bit more info. David Haye broke his
right hand at some point in the fight and he still almost knocked out
Valuev in the 12th round. FACT!!
It might be useful to watch some of the fight then you can establish
some FACTS for yourself.
According to your way of thinking George Foreman should have been
handed victory over Ali in the famous "
rumble in the jungle"
simply because we all know he had a much harder punch. But once
again the harder puncher failed to land the killer blow and he was
knocked out. FACT!!
Anyone that watches the world’s strongest man competition will
know the current world’s strongest man (and the man who has won
the competition more times than anybody else) is
Mariusz Pudzianowski FACT!!
Now here is another interesting FACT about weight, strength and power.
Mariusz weighs about 20 stone and most of his main rivals weigh upto
30 stone or more that’s 1.5 times his weight (that’s a much bigger weight
difference than Valuev and Haye and just like in boxing extra weight is a
huge natural advantage) but he has proved 5 times that pound for pound
he is stronger than all his main rivals. FACT!!
boxing can become extinct for all I care.
That’s fine I accept your opinion here but as you clearly don’t like boxing
when did you discover how hard Valuev punches? Please tell me where
you got this information from? Or is this simply based on the FACT that
he weighs 22.5 stone. I love boxing and most other fighting sports but
I have no idea how hard Valuev punches and I bet you don’t either.
Your view is bigger man = harder punch = guaranteed victory.
This doesn’t make sense. FACT!!
Did you read my most recent reply in the following
thread?
I notice you haven’t sent me a PM. Send me a PM and I’ll send you some more hard FACTS!!
You say "it appeared to you" which is my point exactly, its pure speculation
That’s true but at least I’m basing my opinion on the FACT that Haye
almost knocked him out in the 12th round. Anybody that watched the
whole fight or the highlights will know this is yet another FACT!!
Nobody really won because it goes to score cards and is based on someone's opinion.
I'll just stick with mixed martial arts....boxing can become extinct for all I care.
You are clearly saying that victory should not be awarded to the person
the judges believe won (and that’s what they are paid for in many sports.
good or bad) but to the person who has the harder punch. This doesn’t
make sense. FACT!!
You can't allow a fight to continue until there is a clear winner.
That will lead to many more deaths in fighting sports. FACT!!
Obviously if there was a clear KO there would be little or no room for
argument and it would have been more entertaining but in the real
world of fighting sports this doesn't always happen.
And correct me if I’m wrong but don’t most if not all fighting sports
including “
mixed martial arts” use judges? So if you are correct
unless someone is knocked out in mixed martial arts no one really
wins either.
I quote on mixed martial arts: “Victory in a match is normally gained either
by the judges' decision after an allotted amount of time has elapsed, a
stoppage by the referee (for example if a competitor can not defend himself
intelligently) or the fight doctor (due to an injury), a submission, by a
competitor's cornerman throwing in the towel, or by knockout.” FACT!!
There’s a whole lot of FACTS here. I rest my case. All the best. :2 cents: :thumbsup: