I'm a fan of hers too, but it sounds like you just said that his opinion doesn't matter because it differs from yours.
No.. I'm saying that, in a thread dedicated to this girl that has ran for over 15 pages, his opinion that "she's nothing special" is both arrogant and presumptuous. Taking the time to post something negative about ANY girl in a thread dedicated to that girl is just begging for attention, and is hypocritical.