Interesting thread. Personally, I'm an open-minded guy, and I can see both sides of the argument.
Having said that, I have no real preferance. I love both regular/natural tits, as well as salene & silicone implants, when done correctly and small enough. Roxanne Hall's bolt-ons, as well as the always lovely Sophie Dee who recently had her's done, are prime examples of good tit-jobs done perfectly right, and them staying younger and more healthy & atractive looking for even longer. As long as the ladies themselves maintain a fine, fairly healthy self-esteem, no the rupture risks and have no ruptures and health problems, I feel there is absolutely nothing wrong with fake tits. I have honestly been shocked over the last two years, looking over the "What turns you off in the adult film industry" thread many of us post on, and to see just how many are turned-off my fake tits, and yet, this IS the adult film & adult modeling industry, and let's face it, they're here to stay and many men (like me) certainly don't mind'em.
Never sucked on'em or felt on a pair before. However, I once knew a few cute Chinese-Canadian chick from the greater Vancouver area, who oddly enough lived in the red state in which I grew up in towards the last two years of my suburbanite years in the small city in which I mostly grew up (my famly ebcause of my mother & father's jobs tended to move around after a while almost like a military brat family), and she got a tit job done (it's when salene implants first started to come out, and she showed me and two other co-workers with a flash for two whole seconds or so, and I was a happy lad.
So I'm all for'em, especially when done correctly with a good/skilled surgeon.
HOWEVER, I will admit that once a woman goes over a full C-cup, I feel it often just plain reeks of having self-esteem issues of some kind; don't ask me why. For example, after her fine second (or was it 3rd?) pair of implants, WHY did an other wise nearly perfect looking Daphne Rosen, get a SUB-TERRIBLE tit-job (way too damn big for her frame) as well as ass implants (I believe, and I'm actually more of an Ass-Man myself then a Tit-Man) and a just plain fucking awful and unneeded lip injection done? When it is done such as that, then in my mind, it completely ruins a woman for me as a fantasy object.