I'd also have to opt for India over Danica. I have no idea what India looks like without makeup, but I've seen Danica without makeup (and she was much younger than she is now), and she wasn't all that cute to my eyes. She's not ugly by any stretch, she just didn't do anything for me. But with makeup, she and India do look amazingly alike.
I'll tell you someone else who I always thought resembled
Danica Patrick: Chica (from Chica's Place). Chica has a darker complexion and I think that she's a good deal prettier than Danica. But before Chica got the D cup "enhancements", I'm surprised that she didn't get stopped and asked for autographs - I think they both live in Scottsdale, AZ. And I think they're even close to the same height, build and are roughly the same age +/-. When I first saw early pics of Chica wearing sunglasses, that's what instantly came to my mind. If Chica ever crashes the family car, I'd pay to have it fixed just to see her squint her eyes, stomp her feet and start screaming,
"It's not my fault!!!" - doin' The Danica Stomp.
If Danica didn't have such a big head/ego and a shitty personality, maybe I'd find her more attractive. Cause I think India Summer is hot as hell!!!