For Families of Muslim 9/11 Victims, A New Pain

http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2010-09-03-1Amuslims911_CV_N.htm

Excerpt:

By Rick Hampson, USA TODAY
NEW YORK — After that cruel day nine Septembers ago, Talat Hamdani felt twice victimized: first by fellow Muslims who killed her son, then by fellow Americans who doubted that a Muslim like her Salman died a hero at the World Trade Center.

Now, Hamdani says that with anti-Muslim feeling aroused by plans for an Islamic community center and mosque two blocks from the Ground Zero site, she again feels like a double victim.

"It's worse now than it was then," says Hamdani, a retired middle school English teacher who supports the project. Despite feeling an anti-Muslim backlash in the weeks after the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, she says, "at least there was empathy then. I got tons of support. Now I'm getting hate mail."

Hamdani is one of hundreds of American Muslims who lost loved ones on 9/11, yet found themselves tarred, because of their faith, by the attacks. As 9/11's ninth anniversary approaches, some of these Muslims worry that the controversy over the mosque near Ground Zero is feeding a revival of the Islamophobia of 2001.

FBI statistics show that hate crimes against Muslims remain relatively rare. But recent headlines reflect tension over Muslims' place in America: A young man is accused of stabbing a Muslim cab driver in New York City last month. A Florida preacher plans to mark Sept. 11 by publicly burning Qurans. Across the nation, groups oppose plans to build mosques, including ones proposed by moderate congregations.

Yet 9/11 had more Muslim victims (about 60 of nearly 3,000 killed) than terrorist hijackers (19).

They included an assistant bank vice president and a cook, a commodities trader and a waiter, an insurance executive, a security guard and an IT guy.

They included immigrants from all over: Sarah Khan, a cafeteria manager from Guyana; Syed Abdul Fatha, a copy machine operator from India; Zuhtu Ibis, a computer technician from Turkey. There was Michael Baksh, a Pakistani immigrant on his first day of work at the insurance firm Marsh & McLennan, and Abdoul Karim Traore, who had risen at 3 a.m. that day to deliver USA TODAY before reporting to work as a cook at Windows on the World restaurant. Karamo Trerra, a computer tech, was ready to celebrate his fourth wedding anniversary on Sept. 12.

And there was Salman Hamdani, who apparently abandoned his commute to work that morning to offer his skills as an EMT and police cadet at the Trade Center.

====

Typical right-wing response: "Well, them Mozlems shoulda done better at smackin' down the extremists in their ranks, the way we Christians do!!"

Yeah, right:

http://www.wnd.com/?pageId=21224

Excerpt:

The U.S. State Department is protesting "at the highest level" evangelist Pat Robertson's comments on his television program suggesting its Foggy Bottom headquarters be blown up with a nuclear weapon.


Pat Robertson

Richard Boucher, spokesman for the State Department, called the remarks, made last week on Robertson's "700 Club" program, "despicable."

"I lack sufficient capabilities to express my disdain," Boucher told reporters when asked about the comments. "I think the very idea, though, is despicable."

Robertson is aware of Secretary of State Colin Powell's extreme outrage at the tone and content of the remarks, a senior official told Agence France-Presse.

"That's not the way one expresses an opinion in Washington," the official said.

The remarks came during an interview with National Review columnist Joel Mowbray, who also is a critic of the State Department.

Robertson referred to Mowbray's new book, "Dangerous Diplomacy: How the State Department Threatens American Security," which alleges the agency appeases sponsors of terrorism, ignores U.S. citizens abroad who are in trouble and mishandles visas, to the detriment of security.

The evangelist said after he read Mowbray's book, he thought, 'If I could just get a nuclear device inside Foggy Bottom, I think that's the answer,'" Robertson said, according to a transcript on the website of his Christian Broadcasting Network.

"I mean, you get through this, and you say [to yourself], 'We've got to blow that thing up.' I mean, is it as bad as you say?" Robertson asked.

"It is," Mowbray responded.

==
So tell us again how Robertson was punished for saying that???? Forget any official consequence for his veiled threat (or incitement), what about the reaction from his viewers?? Did his donations go down after he said that??

apologies for the dirty link to WorldNutDaily, but I thought I'd offer that to avoid the cries of "liberal bias!!!" if I included a link to any other source. (You know, the way that CNN, who gave Glenn Beck his on-air start, and still employs Eric fucking Erickson, is the 'Communist News Network'!)...
 

jod0565

Member, you member...
Still, you can't change the sentiment that day brought. just move on and hope for the best.
 
I stopped reading after the alleged "typical right-wing response". Caring about the rights of Muslims is one thing. Using the issue to insult right-wingers is something else.
 

meesterperfect

Hiliary 2020
Demonizing Muslims is fun :bowdown:

who's demonizing who?
think about it.

100's of muslims died on sept 11th?
100's?

boo frikin hoo......how much money has this person recieved from the fed gov, the state gov, insurance companies and charities?
boo frikin hoo.
 
Nearly 3,000 murdered by muslims in the name of Islam. Sorry but I'm all out of sympathy.
 
I think calling Robertson's statements an 'incitement' is a bit sensational. Incitement implies that one is encouraging those with the means to act on a suggestion or a supposed course of action. Which of Robertson's followers has a nuclear weapon? Defending one side of an issue while bashing those who feel the opposite way is not at all serving to promote a solution or understanding, its just serving to further divide people, creating an even greater us vs them sentiment. People are pissed off about this, whether or not you see that or agree with it. Just accept it, and stop your morally pretentious crusade against people you disagree with. Just take solace in the fact that you're ethically superior to those people who disagree with you and be over it.
 
who's demonizing who?
think about it.

100's of muslims died on sept 11th?
100's?

boo frikin hoo......how much money has this person recieved from the fed gov, the state gov, insurance companies and charities?
boo frikin hoo.

I must be convenient for you that you can so easily put a price on human life.
 

L3ggy

Special Operations FOX-HOUND
I believe Robert Nesta Marley And The Wailers said it best.

Your Life Is Worth Much More Than Gold.
 
Because 19 integrists hijacked a few planes and killed 3.000 people the whole occidental world thinks every siglke muslim is a potential terrorist wanting to destroy his country, his values, his way of life and bring Charia to the entire planet...

This is really sad 'cause thinking this way makes people no better than the 19 terrorists.
 

Vlad The Impaler

Power Slave
Like I'm gonna read more of this whiny bullshit. I'm watching natgeo right now. There were thousands of them on that attack and their reasons and rewards they thought they were getting are truly fucking disgusting. Fuck Islam. And fuck their sympathetic right left middle whatever the fuck you are.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

meesterperfect

Hiliary 2020
who's demonizing who?
think about it.

100's of muslims died on sept 11th?
100's?

boo frikin hoo......how much money has this person recieved from the fed gov, the state gov, insurance companies and charities?
boo frikin hoo.

I must be convenient for you that you can so easily put a price on human life.

the federal government put a price on their lives.
the charity organizers put a price on their lives.
the state of new york put a price on their lives.
the court system put a price on their lives.
the airlines put a price on their lives.
and the victims families put a price on their lives
all of them did, literally.
I didn't.
 
Like I'm gonna read more of this whiny bullshit. I'm watching natgeo right now. There were thousands of them on that attack and their reasons and rewards they thought they were getting are truly fucking disgusting. ********. And fuck their sympathetic right left middle whatever the fuck you are.

Please go through the quote:
This was Mumbai’s own 9/11; and yet, unlike the assault on New York City and Washington, in which the killers perished in the first minutes of their meticulous dastardliness, Mumbai’s trauma lasted three whole days, with the terrorists at large, seemingly unstoppable, shooting people at close quarters, breaking down doors, slitting throats, hurling grenades, taking and killing hostages…and making phone calls.
---------
The terrorists killed 170 people; nine of the 10 terrorists were killed, and one—Ajmal Amir Kasab—was captured alive. Imagine the consternation when he turned out to be a brainwashed tool, a Pakistani peasant with no clear thoughts of his own, a man who was taught that, on being martyred, his body would emanate a sweet scent and his face would begin to glow. After Kasab’s colleagues were killed, the Mumbai police took him to the morgue to see their bodies. “We broke him psychologically,” a senior policeman says. In the morgue, Kasab saw no glowing faces, and detected no sweet scent; all he saw were the mangled, hideous, unheavenly corpses of his fellow terrorists. He knew, then, that “he had been taken for a ride.” In such primitive belief rests the fate of the innocent.

From: http://www.thedailybeast.com/blogs-and-stories/2009-11-19/reliving-mumbais-911/?cid=hp:mainpromo8

I would only request you not to hate the religion, hate them who uses the religion to serve their own purpose. They are in every country of the world, in every religion. Humanity should prevail over all else.
 
Top