Bree Olson: Future XRCO Hall-of-Famer, or not?

[wmonbear]

Current XRCO Hall of Famers along with year inducted:

1985: Georgina Spelvin 1985: Tina Russell 1985: Rene Bond 1985: Marilyn Chambers 1985: Sharon Thorpe 1986: Annette Haven 1987: Leslie Bovee 1988: Sharon Mitchell 1988: Colleen Brennan 1989: Sharon Kane 1989: Gloria Leonard 1990: Kay Parker 1990: Suzanne McBain 1991: Seka 1991: Veronica Hart 1991: Erica Boyer 1992: Vanessa del Rio 1993: Desireé Cousteau 1993: Lisa De Leeuw 1994: Hyapatia Lee 1994: Debi Diamond 1995: Shanna McCullough 1995: Ginger Lynn 1995: Christy Canyon 1996: Amber Lynn 1996: Nina Hartley 1997: Desiree West 1997: Jeanna Fine 1998: Bionca 1998: Careena Collins 1999: Kelly Nichols 1999: Annie Sprinkle 1999: Barbara Dare 1999: Jessie St. James 1999: Shauna Grant 1999: Linda Wong 2000: Tori Welles 2001: Porsche Lynn 2001: Tracey Adams 2002: Teri Weigel 2003: Ashlyn Gere 2003: Tiffany Mynx 2004: Selena Steele 2005: Jenna Jameson 2006: Keisha 2006: Kylie Ireland 2007: Francesca Le 2007: Janine 2007: Serenity 2008: Chloe 2008: Nikki Dial 2008: Shayla LaVeaux 2008: Jeannie Pepper 2008: Stephanie Swift 2009: Jewel De'Nyle 2009: Angel Kelly 2009: Leena La Bianca 2009: Missy 2009: Joanna Storm 2009: Stacy Valentine 2010: Sunset Thomas 2010: Inari Vachs 2010: Nikki Charm 2010: Jada Fire 2011: Rayveness 2011: Tricia Devereaux 2011: Jessica Drake 2011: Lynn LeMay 2011: Juli Ashton 2011: Aurora Snow 2012: Julia Ann 2012: Jesse Jane 2013: Belladonna 2013: Lisa Ann 2013: Alexandra Silk 2014: Rebecca Bardoux 2014: Tera Patrick 2014: Stormy Daniels 2014: Taylor Wane


Of the porn stars not yet voted in, Tori Black and Sasha Grey, for example, are pretty much "givens" and may very well be inducted in 2015. But what about some of the other seasoned “star” performers.
From a fan perspective, it would be interesting to speculate their worthiness for induction into XRCO’s "Hall" as well. In this particular poll, we'll examine fan sentiment with respect to the hypothetical nomination of Ms. Bree Olson for the XRCO Hall of Fame.

 

[Ace Boobtoucher]

Why did you put quotation marks around the word GIVEN? Are you implying they are going to be inducted or voted in ironically? And who gives a fuck about the x-rated critics organization? Or any hall of fame that you are infatuated with? Did you copy and paste this list from their website and not cite it properly?

 

[Mr_Stiffy]

I considered Bree a flavour of the month/flash in the pan type personally.

 

[bobjustbob]

XRCO Awards and Hall of Fame. How does sucking a dick turns into some sort of art form? A bunch of guys trying to be important because they write about the porn they watch. They throw a party once a year and try to get porn people to buy tickets by nominating them. Hand some a $20 trophy and hope they come back next year. Same as the AVN and other organizations. Do you really think that some specially select group use some collection of stringent standards to nominate and award?

 

[wmonbear]

XRCO Awards and Hall of Fame. How does sucking a dick turns into some sort of art form? A bunch of guys trying to be important because they write about the porn they watch. They throw a party once a year and try to get porn people to buy tickets by nominating them. Hand some a $20 trophy and hope they come back next year. Same as the AVN and other organizations. Do you really think that some specially select group use some collection of stringent standards to nominate and award?

Like it or not, XRCO is the only credible Hall of Fame organization in existence dedicated to the porn industry. I use the word "credible" to distinguish it from AVN's Hall of Fame which seemingly let's everyone and their grandmother in. Comparing the two organizations, it's quite obvious which one has the higher standards.

Though I don't fully endorse each and every XRCO selection, a close look at their HOF members-listing suggests that its selection process is taken very seriously. The names, for the most part, read like an All-time-Best-of-Porn list.
That being said, there are 3 names from the Golden Age that are mysteriously missing, which I view as glaring oversights. They are:

Rachel Ashley - simply the sexiest woman I have ever seen in my life! - mainstream or otherwise
Lois Ayres, and
Danielle Martin

 

[bobjustbob]

Sorry to digress. The whole awarding process is something that I have a very strong opinion about. Back to the subject.

What makes Bree Olson's dick sucking any less deserving of Hall of Fame worthy than Tori Black or Sasha Grey? Is it the swirl of the tongue? Does she not drool and spit as well as those others? Sure her ball lapping leaves something to be desired but her lip work from the sides are unique and deserve consideration. Certainly Tori is the star with her stroking while sucking on the head, much deserved of HOF. Yet when one considers Bree's combined gagging noises and handless deep throating, you have to admit that no other star can duplicate. Sasha is the Queen of Slop and Bree will never come close. But is it fair to compare Bree to this one dimensional dick sucker?

Dick sucking is a very important component to porn HOF status but it is not the only thing. Getting plowed from behind is it's own specialty and needs it's own considerations. All of these women take the same sized dicks. They have also shared the same male talent but most of what slides back there is different male talent. So how can we separate the 3? Is it fair to judge by common male talent or how they handle the others? Bree brings the old school doggie style home every time. Sasha spoons very well but don't discount Bree because she doesn't get enough plowing in that position from her directors.

Taking a thick gooey load in the face should put Bree over the top for HOF. Her expressions and positioning for the money shot are as good as any already in the hall. Always enthusiastic and never letting the cum go anywhere other than her face. Always smiling while swirling the load with her fingers all around her face and onto her lips. She excels in gurgling and blowing cum bubbles while squeezing the last drops out. A definite consideration for HOF, What do you think?

 

[FreeOnes_Adam]

Sorry to digress. The whole awarding process is something that I have a very strong opinion about. Back to the subject.

What makes Bree Olson's dick sucking any less deserving of Hall of Fame worthy than Tori Black or Sasha Grey? Is it the swirl of the tongue? Does she not drool and spit as well as those others? Sure her ball lapping leaves something to be desired but her lip work from the sides are unique and deserve consideration. Certainly Tori is the star with her stroking while sucking on the head, much deserved of HOF. Yet when one considers Bree's combined gagging noises and handless deep throating, you have to admit that no other star can duplicate. Sasha is the Queen of Slop and Bree will never come close. But is it fair to compare Bree to this one dimensional dick sucker?

Dick sucking is a very important component to porn HOF status but it is not the only thing. Getting plowed from behind is it's own specialty and needs it's own considerations. All of these women take the same sized dicks. They have also shared the same male talent but most of what slides back there is different male talent. So how can we separate the 3? Is it fair to judge by common male talent or how they handle the others? Bree brings the old school doggie style home every time. Sasha spoons very well but don't discount Bree because she doesn't get enough plowing in that position from her directors.

Taking a thick gooey load in the face should put Bree over the top for HOF. Her expressions and positioning for the money shot are as good as any already in the hall. Always enthusiastic and never letting the cum go anywhere other than her face. Always smiling while swirling the load with her fingers all around her face and onto her lips. She excels in gurgling and blowing cum bubbles while squeezing the last drops out. A definite consideration for HOF, What do you think?

I fapped to this.

 

[wmonbear]

Of the porn stars not yet voted in, Tori Black and Sasha Grey, for example, are pretty much "givens" and may very well be inducted in 2015...

You could also add Jenna Haze to this list of shoe-ins not yet voted in.

 

[RASQ]

A bunch of guys trying to be important because they write about the porn they watch.

or create polls and hall of fame bullshit like womb bear.

 

[himperv203]

no... there are many other pornstars who deserve it better

 

[wmonbear]

no... there are many other pornstars who deserve it better

TOTALLY agree! Despite her popularity several years ago when she won the 2010 Miss Freeones Contest, I voted
a resounding NO on the prospect of Bree becoming a member of the XRCO Hall of Fame.

 

[cestmoi2010]

You could also add Jenna Haze to this list of shoe-ins not yet voted in.

100% agree that Jenna is a LOCK. Also agree on Tori and Sasha. Think it is looking good for Kortney Kane to eventually get in

Was floored to see a few names NOT on this list

Racquel Darrian - if she isn't the most beautiful woman in Porn History she is in the discussion. How she is not in is laughable

Nikki Tyler also merits discussion

Rocki Roads - just saying her name conveys images of a drop-dead stunner with a pair of "Rocki Roads" that were as incredible as it gets

Dasha http://www.freeones.com/html/d_links/Dasha/ - drop-dead stunning and she did it ALL............She was shaven down there, gave great BJs, did Anal and more. She should be IN

Nicole Sheridan - Tall and stunning and NO ONE had a nastier mouth when jerking the guy off to completion as she did. She made it seem like she would die without the guy's cum. If they are waiting so she and her hubby can be put in together I am OK with it but she should be IN

 

[bobjustbob]

Like it or not, XRCO is the only credible Hall of Fame organization in existence dedicated to the porn industry. I use the word "credible" to distinguish it from AVN's Hall of Fame which seemingly let's everyone and their grandmother in. Comparing the two organizations, it's quite obvious which one has the higher standards.

Though I don't fully endorse each and every XRCO selection, a close look at their HOF members-listing suggests that its selection process is taken very seriously. The names, for the most part, read like an All-time-Best-of-Porn list.

You better not tell that to XRCO. Half of their members are AVN writers. XBiz won't be too happy either since some of their writers are XRCO members and they hand out awards also. Unless you have personally served as a member of an organization that actually has annual awards and has a brick and mortar HOF, don't tell me how the system works. I know what goes on and have been participating in the process for many years. It's politics and money plain and simple. XRCO are just a bunch of people wanting to be relevant. Do you understand that this is porn? There is no art involved. Book a time to film, put it in the can a sell it. Nobody relies upon critical reviews before they make their purchase. Opinions are like assholes, everybody's got one.

 

[wmonbear]

You better not tell that to XRCO. Half of their members are AVN writers. XBiz won't be too happy either since some of their writers are XRCO members and they hand out awards also. Unless you have personally served as a member of an organization that actually has annual awards and has a brick and mortar HOF, don't tell me how the system works. I know what goes on and have been participating in the process for many years. It's politics and money plain and simple. XRCO are just a bunch of people wanting to be relevant. Do you understand that this is porn? There is no art involved. Book a time to film, put it in the can a sell it. Nobody relies upon critical reviews before they make their purchase. Opinions are like assholes, everybody's got one.

I have no interest whatsoever in critics' reviews or awards disseminated by XRCO related to dvd titles.
Instead, this thread and others like it, are about select pornstars, and the associated
sentiment (positive or negative) held by fans regarding their careers.

Whatever the method XRCO employs to determine their HOF inductees, the results are clearly more exclusive than the AVN alternative.

For example, AVN includes in their hall of fame a host of merely "good" performers in addition to the standard legendary porn names that can be found on most 'best of' lists. Here (imo) are some of AVN's questionable inductions:

Jada Fire
Raquel Devine
Alexander DeVoe
Gail Force Melissa Hill
Janet Jacme
Rebecca Lord
Cara Lott
Shy Love
Chelsea Manchester
Tami Monroe
Britt Morgan
Katie Morgan
Bionca
Bunny Bleu
Ashley Blue
Skye Blue
Vanessa Blue
Mary Carey
Gia Darling
Madison Stone
Sydnee Steele
Taylor St. Claire
Sheri St. Claire
Jasmin St. Claire
Savanna Samson

 

[wmonbear]

A simple majority (e.g. 51%) is insufficient to suggest a particular porn star should be inducted into a hall of fame.
Commonly, a two-thirds majority threshold is typically used to determine whether a nomination warrants passage.
Clearly lacking a mandate (only 50% support as of this post), the notion of Bree Olson as a hall-of-famer at this point
appears to be unmerited.

That being said, it is still very early in the survey. Early projections does not necessarily portend outcome.

 

[cestmoi2010]

Roxanne Hall

For her not to have been inducted by now is a JOKE unless she is not eligible. Roxanne has a long career and done lots of scenes and is VERY HOF worthy

 

[bigwarmload]

.
I doubt Bree Olson is even in Charlie Sheen's top 10 porn star hall of fame that he has slept with, if she cant make that why should she be in this one? :dunno: :nono: :rofl2:

 

[Ace Bandage]

It's a made up, fairy tale HOF like everything else you fucking post about. It doesn't exist. It doesn't fucking matter. It's stupid. One day, I hope you get ran over by a snow plow, attacked by ravenous wolverines, doused in gasoline, and set on fire. That would be awesome. And it would prevent you from posting this inane and worthless bullshit. Why do you care so much about porn and that erotic picture bullshit? How sad and pathetic is your life?

Why the fuck would there be a porn HOF? And why would anyone care about it? Induct whoever the fuck you want. It's meaningless. It's just fucking sex. Why the fuck would there be a hall of fame for something like that? You don't get to have a hall of fame for doing something required to advance the species.

Can you go the fuck away? Why don't you go deep sea diving with nitrous tanks instead of oxygen?

 

[John_8581]

I'm glad to see that:

:lovecoupl Janine Lindemulder, and Francesca Le got voted in during 2007; Jessica Drake and Julia Ann in 2011; Tera Patrick Stormy Daniels and Taylor Wane in during 2014. :lovecoupl

Sasha Grey, Tori Black ... most definitely. Because their work was so unique.

Bree Olson? A pornstar whose career lasted only four and half years (2006 to 2010)? Exactly what Bobjustbob is saying. And for that ... No. Bree Olson doesn't belong in there.

Girls more deserving than Bree Olson in my opinion:

Nina Mercedez, Hanna Hilton, Nikki Benz, Kirsten Price, Alektra Blue, Sunrise Adams, McKenzie Lee, Kelly Madison, Deauxma, Puma Swede and Sara Jay.

 

[D-rock]

How does sucking a dick turns into some sort of art form?

Then again, kicking or throwing a ball in a sport isn't exactly an art form either.


In any case, no, Bree Olson doesn't belong in any sort of hall of fame.