I don't have a Naughty America membership, so I can't comment on them. But I do have a BangBros membership, and I can tell you that I wouldn't recommend getting a membership there.
The only thing saving BangBros sites from being a complete waste of internet space is the large number of performers they have and the large amount of content. (The performer directories in my sig proves this). Otherwise, this may be the least professional sites, for ones that are so large, in the history of porn.
- They have many girls, but the guys are so annoying, they completely distract from whatever eroticism that the female performers might generate. These guys are idiots. I can't stress that enough. What makes it worse is that if you are watching a 30 minute video, the first 20 minutes is the setup, which consists of you listening to them talk. Only 10 minutes of the video is actual sex.
- The production quality has to be the poorest of any porn site....ever! The video quality is hit or miss, mostly miss. Not only is the quality poor, they don'y know how to shoot a scene. Between the bad positioning and angles, inability to keep the camera still, and shooting things like the back of a performers head for minutes at a time, you quickly learn how to use the fast forward button.
- Not only is the video quality poor, the still pictures must have been taken by a monkey with a camera. The person who takes them must be high while he's doing it because half of them are blurry, or the lighting changes from picture to picture.
- Until recently, crediting the performers was not their major concern. You never knew the actual identity of the performer you were watching. (This is a problem on man websites)
Unfortunately for me, quality of content is not my major concern. I like to keep up with who's who and there may be no better site that has a larger range of professional to amateur performers.
